The TARDIS landed in 2024 with a whole new Doctor and a fresh era for the beloved sci-fi series. Ncuti Gatwa took the reins as the Fourteenth Doctor, joined by his companion Ruby Sunday (Millie Gibson).
The move to Disney+ and a new showrunner, Russell T Davies (returning after his successful run in the early 2000s), promised a return to the show’s classic charm. But how did it fare with fans and critics? Here’s a breakdown of the highs and lows of Doctor Who 2024.
A New Doctor, a Familiar Face
The most significant change was undoubtedly the Doctor themself. Ncuti Gatwa brought youthful energy and a quirky charisma to the role. Reviews praised his comedic timing and ability to connect with viewers.
Comparisons were inevitably drawn to Matt Smith’s Tenth Doctor, another Doctor known for his youthful enthusiasm. However, Gatwa quickly established his own take on the character, with a vulnerability and warmth that resonated with audiences.
Russell T Davies’ return as showrunner was another major talking point. His era is often considered a golden age for Doctor Who, known for its exciting adventures, relatable characters, and a healthy dose of camp. Those expecting a complete return to Davies’ earlier style might have been surprised. The season embraced a more whimsical and lighthearted tone, with a focus on fun, fast-paced stories.
Classic Capers and New Companions
The season explored a variety of classic Who tropes: historical adventures, encounters with quirky aliens, and threats to the universe itself. One episode, “The Melody Man,” harkened back to the show’s musical roots with a villain who stole music throughout time.
Another, “The Library of Lost Souls,” paid homage to the vast knowledge and history housed within the TARDIS.
Millie Gibson’s Ruby Sunday was a bright spot for many viewers. Her character, a quick-witted teenager from present-day London, provided a grounded perspective amidst the fantastical situations.
The Doctor and Ruby’s dynamic was a highlight, with a strong sense of friendship and mutual respect.
The Disneyfication Debate
The move to Disney+ was a significant change, with some fans apprehensive about the platform’s influence. While the production value received praise, some felt the show lacked the grittier edge it occasionally possessed on the BBC.
There were concerns that the season catered more towards a younger audience, with a lighter tone and less complex storytelling.
Another point of contention was the perceived “Disneyfication” of the series. Some long-time fans felt the show lost some of its bite, becoming overly sentimental and formulaic.
The emphasis on humor and lightheartedness didn’t sit well with everyone who craved the show’s darker moments.
Critical Consensus: A Mixed Bag
Reviews for Doctor Who 2024 were divided. Critics praised Gatwa’s performance, the return of Davies, and the show’s ability to recapture the spirit of classic Who.
They lauded the return to a more episodic format, offering self-contained adventures that were easy to jump into for new viewers.
However, some reviewers found the stories to be predictable and lacking in depth. The lighter tone, while enjoyable, didn’t resonate with everyone.
There were criticisms that the season felt aimed more at children than the show’s traditional audience.
Fan Reactions: Divided Opinions
Fan reactions mirrored the critical reception. Many viewers adored Gatwa’s Doctor and the return of Davies’ signature style.
The lighthearted adventures and focus on fun were a welcome change for some. The reintroduction of classic elements like historical settings and quirky aliens pleased long-time fans.
However, a significant portion of the fanbase expressed disappointment. Some felt the season lacked the emotional weight and complex narratives of previous eras.
The perceived “Disneyfication” alienated some who preferred the show’s edgier moments. Disagreements arose over the portrayal of the companion, with some finding Ruby Sunday underdeveloped.
The Future of Doctor Who
Despite the mixed reactions, Doctor Who 2024 has garnered a dedicated fanbase. The season finale left several plot threads dangling, hinting at a larger story arc to come in future seasons.
With Davies returning for another season, fans can expect more adventures with the Fourteenth Doctor and Ruby Sunday.
Doctor Who’s ability to regenerate, both in terms of its characters and creative vision, has always been a key part of its success.
While 2024 might not have pleased everyone, it represents a new chapter for the beloved series. Whether it finds its footing and captures the hearts of a new generation, or alienates some long-time viewers, only time, and the TARDIS itself, will tell.
FAQs
Who is the new Doctor?
Ncuti Gatwa takes the mantle as the Fourteenth Doctor! He brings a youthful energy and quirky charisma to the role, drawing comparisons to Matt Smith’s Tenth Doctor while establishing his own unique take on the Time Lord.
Is Russell T Davies back?
Yes! The showrunner behind the 2005 relaunch returned for Doctor Who 2024. While not a complete return to his earlier style, the season captured a similar spirit with exciting adventures and relatable characters.
What’s the deal with Disney+?
The move to Disney+ brought a higher production value, but also concerns about “Disneyfication.” Some fans felt the show lost its edge, becoming more lighthearted and formulaic.
Is the new season good?
Reviews were mixed. Critics praised Gatwa’s performance, Davies’ return, and the fun, fast-paced stories. However, some found the plots predictable and the tone too light.
What about the companion?
Millie Gibson’s Ruby Sunday received positive reviews. Her quick wit and grounded perspective balanced the Doctor’s whimsy. However, some viewers felt her character wasn’t fully developed.
Is it like the old Doctor Who?
The season reintroduced classic elements like historical settings and quirky aliens, pleasing long-time fans. However, others felt it relied too heavily on nostalgia and lacked the emotional weight of earlier eras.
What’s next for Doctor Who?
The cliffhanger ending hints at a larger arc in future seasons. With Davies returning, expect more adventures with the Fourteenth Doctor and Ruby Sunday (or maybe a new companion!).
Is it worth watching?
Whether you’ll enjoy Doctor Who 2024 depends on your preferences. If you like Gatwa’s Doctor, Davies’ style, and lighthearted adventures, you’ll likely have a good time. However, if you crave darker storylines and complex narratives, you might be disappointed.
Where can I find more information?
You can find reviews, discussions, and fan theories online:
- Review websites like Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes
- Fan communities on Reddit and social media
- YouTube channels dedicated to Doctor Who
Ultimately, the best way to decide if you enjoy Doctor Who 2024 is to watch it yourself! The TARDIS awaits!
To read more, click here.
Leave a Reply